How to Handle Returns & Customer Service After the Christmas Period

The weeks following the festive period can be one of the busiest and overwhelming times of the year for customer service teams. With gift returns, exchanges and post-Christmas queries piling up, businesses must be prepared to handle the surge efficiently. A smooth returns process not only protects your brand reputation, but it also strengthens customer loyalty at a time when many consumers are forming opinions about whether they’ll shop with you again. Here’s how to manage returns and customer service effectively once the Christmas season has well and truly ended:

Streamline your returns policy

A clear, easy-to-understand returns policy is essential. This is especially the case after Christmas when volume is high and make sure that your policy is visible on your website, receipts and order confirmation emails, simple with straightforward steps that avoid confusion, flexible extended returns windows and transparent conditions, like unopened packaging or proof of purchase. The more accessible the policy, the fewer support queries your team will need to handle.

Prepare your customer support team ahead of time for higher demand

Expect a spike in customer enquiries during January. In order to manage this effectively, you can do things like: increase staffing levels, either temporarily or by reallocating internal resources, provide refresher training on common post-Christmas issues, equip your team with scripts or FAQS to respond quickly and consistently, and, finally, ensure systems are updated, including order histories, return request portals and tracking tools. Prepared teams resolve issues faster and reduce customer frustration. 

Offer multiple return options

Convenience is key to a positive return experience. Multiple options empower customers to choose what works best for them, allowing you to suit their individual needs and requirements in the process. With this in mind, you should consider offering the following things: drop-off points through couriers or parcel shops, in-store returns for online purchases, free returns, even if just for a limited time, pre-paid return labels included with every order and, finally, self-service returns portals for generating labels and tracking status. 

Improve communication throughout the returns process

Clear communication reduces uncertainty and builds trust. Automated systems are especially helpful at this time of year. This is especially the case if you want to allow your team to focus on more complex enquiries that may be more value-added or profit-driving. As such, you should make sure that your customers are receiving at least one or more of the following things:

• Acknowledgement when a return request is submitted
• Confirmation when the parcel is received
• Regular status updates
• Notifications when refunds or exchanges are processed

Maintain a positive, empathetic tone

Post-Christmas can be stressful for customers and clients alike. Long queues, delayed deliveries and gift disappointments are all common. A positive tone can turn a potentially negative experience into an opportunity that builds loyalty. It’s a win-win for everyone involved. If you want to achieve this, then your team should be doing one or more of the following things: approach every interaction with patience and empathy, avoid rigid language, instead offering solutions and alternatives, and take ownership of any issues, even if they weren’t caused directly as a result of your business.

Monitor common issues & fix them in a timely manner

High return rates or repeated complaints can reveal problems with things like: product quality, sizing information, packaging, delivery partners and product descriptions. Collecting insights from the post-Christmas period helps you make improvements that reduce returns in the future. It also helps to enhance your reputation as a company. Customers will have peace of mind knowing that you’re more than happy to authorise refunds or exchanges quickly, without holding onto their money for an unnecessarily long period of time.

Reward customer loyalty once the returns process has been completed 

Once a customer completes a return or exchange, it’s a great time to encourage them to stay engaged with your brand. Consider offering one or more of the following things: discount codes for future purchases, loyalty points, personalised product recommendations and early access to upcoming promotions. In turn, this will transform your returns process, which is often seen as a negative, into a positive, relationship-building experience for both your business and your customers. It’s a win-win for everyone involved, from start to finish. 

Review your internal processes for next year

As soon as Christmas has ended, the rush calms down, and your performance is elevated. Documenting these insights helps you to better prepare for future Christmasses. So, how can you evaluate your performance? Put simply, ask yourself the following questions and go from there:

• Did your return policy work smoothly?
• Were there enough staff to handle demand?
• Were customers satisfied with response times?
• Did shipping partners meet expectations?
• What can be automated or improved?

To conclude

Handling returns and customer service after Christmas doesn’t have to be chaotic. With a clear strategy, strong communication and a customer-first mindset, businesses can turn seasonal challenges into opportunities. They use it as a way to build trust and establish long-term loyalty. A great post-Christmas experience often matters just as much as a successful pre-Christmas sales period, sometimes, even more. In addition, you could also look at creating: 

• A shorter version for social media
• A downloadable guide or checklist
• FAQs for your website or help centre
• Email templates for returns and customer support

Kumo is a full-service digital marketing agency powered by a dedicated, highly experienced team. Based in Nottingham, we work with clients nationwide, helping organisations from a wide range of industries achieve impactful, measurable outcomes. Our services cover SEO, PPC, content marketing, web design and more. Get in touch with our friendly, expert team to discover how we can help move your business forward – we’re always here to support you.